I took my kayak out to Herrington last year and didn't have much luck. I caught a small bass on a rock shelf, but I did see plenty of gar. I don't think it's the best lake for fishing around here, but I'm sure you'll have fun trying. I live in Nicholasville and would love to know if you get any more info because it's pretty close to me and a nice, relaxing spot to hit. Good luck!