I don't think he is overrated. Now, my opinion is not worth a lot because I am not an NFL scout, but from everything I have heard and read from scouts, former players and coaches as that Luck is expected to be a great QB in the league. I have also heard great things about RGIII and that he is a much better pocket passer than people realize. They really raved about him on Mike and Mike this morning. From everything I have heard, RGIII would be the number one overall pick in almost any other year, but he has the unfortunate ciscumstance of coming out when Luck did. All that being said, Andrew Luck's dad is Oliver Luck, the AD at West Virginia. I hope the son does well and I hope the father is caught on tape with a male prostitute in a turkish bathhouse and the video is posted on youtube.