I wouldn't say it's similar to Kincaid. Kincaid has a much higher potential for a wallhanger while Elmer Davis is more of a numbers lake. I have seen a good number of 5+ fish from ED over the last few years but the chances of anything bigger than that go down pretty quickly. It will be a mudhole this weekend like everything else but if you stick with Z-hogs or jigs in dark colors and fish shoreline cover as slow as you can stand it, you should have some success. And don't forget the rattles.