Sorry I did not answer. I figured with the extensive past threads on gear ratios that you would get so many answers, that I need not reply. I guess maybe everyone felt that way.

Personally, I have three different ratios on my boat at all times. Also, the ratio alone does not determine how fast the lure is retrieved. You need to also look at the inches per revolution that is retrieved. For instance, I've seen 5.2:1 that actually retrieve more line per handle turn than a 5.8:1. There are many factors that determine that.

I use 3.8:1 for all my really deep crankbaits. I find it much less tiring. I use 5.2:1 for most of my other fishing with the exception of TX rigging or flipping a jig. Then I use 6.2:1.

It is my opinion, that when using my 6.2:1 to pull a DD22, or even a DT16 through the water, that it is much, much more difficult than using my 3.8:1.

What all this boils down to is this, you have to do what is best for you. Perhaps you could arrange to fish with some folks who have different speeds of reels, and check to see which ones you like the best, for the application YOU are going to be fishing.

I will absolutely extend an offer to you to fish together and let you try several different, OK, three different ratios.

Danny