We are in the same situation. My outboard is in the same shape and even though I want to hit the others, I can't stand the headache. So I've been hitting McNeely and even though it is small, I have been presently surprised. I've gotten plenty of pound, pound and a halfers, with the occassional 21/2 to 3 mixed in. It's not by any means a Nolin or other, but it does satisfy my addiction. Good luck and fish on!