McNeely is definitely the closest. I love Elmer Davis, and I think it's worth the hour and a half drive to Owenton. If you're thinking about maybe some catfish, then Guist is probably your best bet. And there are lots of bankfishing opportunities. In addition to the two that ohiorivercatfisherman mentioned, there's Tom Wallace Lake in Fairdale (excellent access), Fisherman's Park in J'Town, and Miles Park Pond #4 on Shelbyville Rd. They all have bass, bluegill, catfish, and crappie in them.