Got a question for anyone willing to answer.

I put a rattle on my jig for sure when the water is stained and muddy. Most of the time I leave it off in clear water, unless I have fished it for hours without a bite and I'm trying to get the fish to look at it.

Do you think adding a green pumpkin or natural color rattle in clear water hurts my chances of getting bites? Maybe the sound is too much in clear water. Just wondering what you guys think.