Maybe an odd topic here, but need suggestions......

[artcarney_agr]

Bump your bait offering size - when it comes to bluegill, it's hard to beat using small minnows - the bigger bluegill jump all over them and you'll catch bass, crappie, and catfish in the process. The smaller bluegill usually leave them alone.

[stoner]

might try a circle hook

[shemwelljr]

Hey guys, thanks for the helpful replies.

I don't think it is necessarily a timing issue in setting the hook. I'm not perfect, so I'm sure every now and then it could be. However, when the bobber bobs and you set it instantly, that shouldn't be the problem.

I typically use wax worms and smallish hooks. I've tried bigger hooks, and if I try hooks too big, they steal the bait and I never catch anything. I like the treble hook idea, and larger bait. That may work!

As far as leaving the hook in them, I've read that they will live as the hook rusts away, and I've heard the opposite. In reality, I've seen them die, so I don't want to just watch them swim upside down later.

Looks like I may have options. I love to fish, but just don't want to kill animals of any kind needlessly if I can avoid it, certainly not as part of my entertainment in life.

[flyfish]

While I can appreciate your catch and release, I wouldn't get too bent out of shape over a few belly up bluegill. I guarantee they'll sink and a hungry catfish or turtle will thank you for it.

[dc chopper]

bend the barb down or use barbless hooks, thats what I do at some places I bass fish cause I know they try to swallow the hooks, lose some but thtas my choic.

[kybodyman]

You might try changing bobbers. I use the lay down type that stand up before going under. If you set the hook before it rises to full upright position, I bet your gut hooks will be nearly zero. Of course you have to use a very light bait so you float stays horizontal.