Federal Law?

[Jbyrd]

To a certain degree he was right !!! The corp passed a law stating you cannot fish 150 ft of a MOORED object not floating object. And yes the corp is a federal agency. There has been several cases on cumberland the past 2 years. Tickets written but thrown out because they where written by kdfw officers. BUT the judge has warned if it is written by a corp ranger you will go to federal court in London ky and it will be bad... Conley bottom is the only one that is complaining about fisherman around here on cumberland . BUT they have a clause that it is at the marina owners descretion so they can let the buckeyes fish around their boat slips....

[slobslayer]

Sounds like a good excuse to have another "no wake zone" all the way across the lake like they did at Emerald Isle Marina on Green River Lake. You all know we have to keep the Ohio Navy happy.

[southern]

there is the same signs all over the state marina at green now.but i can assure you i will be fishing in there,just play dumb and say you thought they said welcome to good fishing.the houseboat owners over at green think they own the lake.

[Dave Stewart]

All this talk abour the Corps passing laws...now just think about that statement...since when does a government agency pass laws? I was always taught that it was legislative bodies that passed laws, not some government agency or entitiy.

FACT: Bassman is right...check it out in the KDFW Boating and Fishing Guide. It has been there for a few years now...only pertains to those marina's having a contract with the Corps.

[Jbyrd]

Ok let me rephrase it then "THE CORP" proposed a law prohibiting fishing within 150 ft of any moored structure ,then whom ever passes laws "passed" it . ANYWAY same result it is a LAW............... Governed by corp law enforcement which is a FEDERAL agency. And it does say ANY MOORED STRUCTURE marina or other wise . BUT the corp ranger on cumberland said it only comes into play if the structure owner wants to enforce it Thus some confusion and grey area. On cumberland Conley bottoms owner has chosen to not allow bass boats to fish inside the no-wake zone . But people are walking up and down the dock all the time fishing. I ask him one time why was that and his answer was they are paying customers. Which I replied I paid 5 dollar launch fee am I not a paying customer. At which he said a few choice cuss words and walked off......

[Dave Stewart]

Fact: No one passed any law saying any such thing. If it is a law, please post the civil code on here so we can all look it up.

Fact: The Corps does hold jurisdiction over the lakes and the lands surrounding those lakes which were built by the federal government.

Fact: The Corps has entered into a written agreement with some Marina owners that basically gives the Marina owner jurisdiction over the water and land adjacent to the Marina.

Fact: Some of these Marina owners have put up signs that prohibit fishing around the Marina areas....some only prohibit fishing in slips...some within 150 ft. This is what is addressed in the KDFW Boating and Fishing Guide

Fact: If you violate the posted area by fishing there, you will be charged with tresspassing....not charged of some fantasy law that was never passed. You will be issued a ticket for tresspassing if you are caught just like you would be if you walked onto posted land to hunt and were caught doing so.

Fact: There is no agreement between private dock owners and the Corps. There is no law to prohibit you from fishing around a private dock or any other dock that does not have said written agreement with the Corps.

Now, having said all that, the reason these Marina owners started prohibiting fishing around their docks in the first place is the fact some anglers have no respect for the private property of others and damage boats in the slips with their lures etc.....can't blame them.

[Jbyrd]

Not entirely true about fishing the boat slips being the reason for the no fishing signs. At conley bottom before the draw down No one fished the slips , most of them set in 60 -100 ft of water. But the guy at conley was running people of behind the marina in the pockets that where 100 yard from the slips . He just wanted to be a rude obnoxious person.

[Jbyrd]

Also another question: If you are being cited for trespassing aren't the people that are idling thru just as guilty? They are in the same area. Trespass as Webster describes it is as follows: to enter unlawfully upon another's land; to encroach upon another's rights; to make too great a claim; to injure or annoy another. Most trespassing arrest/ tickets are for being in an area one is not allowed to be in doesn't say what you are doing.. ????????

[CTFSHWHISKER]

as hyped up as some you get about this i see now why i'm not catching any dang fish,i never fish around marinas.if these marina owners are paying a lease then if they wish to do this then so be it,from spending alot of time on a hoseboat,at a marina i can tell you Dave is about dead on,some have absolutley no courtesy,and we,they get tired of lures hung in their boats and ropes,and some do take it on themseves to cut them out.besides,on a lake the size of nolin,or the enourmous cumberland,why do you need to fish at the marinas?you have a boat with a nice size motor you can go anywhere,lots of the h-boat owners don't,and therefore the marina owners keep it for them.and as far as paying a $5 fee,that pales in comparison to what it cost to keep a houseboat moored a year.and remember,this law is kinda like speeding,so when those that want to blatantly break it get a ticket,don't be crying about it.