Hi, I am not a guy but I was a wife for 19yrs so i thought I would throw my 2 cents in before the guys did. I agree the fishing equipment wouldnt work if she is not into fishing. Thats too bad. Now I know that women love jewelry so how about a gold necklace with a little heart pendant. Its something she can wear and it will remind her of your love. Ok yes I am a big time romantic.