Both of these trolling motors are good, it is a matter of preference. I will say this, the MG on my boat has been there 6 years.....I have a backup laying in my garage awaiting its turn when needed....it is still laying there until the one on my boat now gives up the ghost. Do you have any idea how many hours that one on my boat has on it in 6 years of bass guiding? I would estimate about 5000 to 6000 hours at least. My only repair has been replacing props and steering cables...those are not going to last when you put as many hours as I do, no matter what brand you buy.

One recommendation...no matter which brand you buy, put a tie down strap and a bounce buster on your trolling motor...they will extend the life of your trolling motor for sure if you fish any rough water.