I think that, if I were you, I would file a complaint with my agent's boss and let them know I was going to follow it all the way to the Commissioner of Insurance if the claim was not paid. If your motorcycle was stolen from the garage, the garage is a part of the house and it, and everything in it, is insured so it would seem to be covered under your homeowner's insurance. If you had parked the motorcycle in your living room and it was stolen, or the house burned down, I'll bet they would have paid your claim. Your agent seems to be splitting hairs over location.
I was recently away from home for a couple of months. Our boat was parked on a slight incline with metal "chocks" blocking the wheels to prevent it from moving. When I returned home I saw a set of tire tracks in the snow that were backed up to the trailer hitch. All that saved us from having it stolen was that we had the type of lock on it that has a guard to prevent bolt cutters. Fortunately we had removed all the fishing gear from the boat and put it in a locked place. We have an umbrella package and insure the house, vehicles, boat, and my jewelry, all with the same company.
I don't like State Farm for anything except financial investments. I've had some problems with them in the past and cancelled all my insurance coverage because of it.
I hope you find your motorcycle and the thug that stole it. Maybe you can issue him some good old fashioned "street justice."




Reply With Quote