Elkhorn Koi?

[ThreeLions]

Are you sure that they aren't small carp?

DAVE

[Denver1911]

No. I am not sure. I am not familiar with all carps and don't even really know much about koi other than that what I see in decorative ponds and the like. These fish did not look like any native Kentucky carp, but sure did look like the fish people call koi. They were goldfish orange and one of them was a combo of goldfish orange and white. Based on what knowledge I have, I'd say they were koi, but they may be some form of non-native carp though.

[dldoss80]

no not carp, they are a big goldfish with long fins just like koi. I worked at a golf course as a teenager and they had the same fish in their ponds, just decorative fish. probably someones that got out of their ponds during a flood. the ones i have seen have been golden and some have been white and gray spots

[ThreeLions]

Check out the Prussian Carp and Goldfish photos in my gallery here: http://www.pbase.com/leighite/fish

These fish were caught in a local pond and were released into that pond by a well-meaning person from their koi pond. Do they look like what you are seeing?

DAVE

[jcb]

I've seen them all my life, I'm pretty sure they are native. Same as you, some orange, some orange/white.

[mhall]

I've seen them all my life, I'm pretty sure they are native. Same as you, some orange, some orange/white.

YEP, Bingo, see them all the time in there in one section I fish and some of them are quite large.

[lunkerbustin]

If you ever go to the hatchery in Peaks Mill you will notice that they feed the pond fish with feeder goldfish. I had a friend that worked there several years ago. When they drain a pond or have a flood these goldfish go into the creek. I have seen several over the years that are quite large.

[dave57]

i am 65 yrs old and i remeber seeing gold fish in the rolling fork river in marion county that my uncle caught when i was just a boy lol.

[KyTrkyHntr]

No. I am not sure. I am not familiar with all carps and don't even really know much about koi other than that what I see in decorative ponds and the like. These fish did not look like any native Kentucky carp, but sure did look like the fish people call koi. They were goldfish orange and one of them was a combo of goldfish orange and white. Based on what knowledge I have, I'd say they were koi, but they may be some form of non-native carp though.

Did you put a fly on them???

[kygorski]

Lincoln park lagoon in chicago is full of them, and guess what? They will hit a small rapala.Found that out by accident while fishing for salmon who return back to the lagoon.

[Denver1911]

Three lions: Not colored like the Prussian carp and not shaped like the wild goldfish.

Jcb, mhall: Native? Are you for real? Not saying you're wrong (I don't know and I know I don't know), but I'd be very surprised. Got anything to make me feel otherwise?

Dave: I was chucking hardware. Of course I pulled a small crank bait past them. I'll take the flyrod next time

[raincheck]

After fishing Elkhorn and i seen some gold fish i decided too get a bow for my next float too shoot them and the carp i seen.Did that as a kid & tought i would try it from my kayak someday.