I finally see where you're going with this, and I can see where someone could end up paying more in taxes, especially since you're going to lump in property taxes and vehicle taxes.
I really don't get hit too bad there, because I've NEVER purchased a new car, and my house is a very modest, AFFORDABLE house.
But I guess someone making 50k and living above their means with 2 30k cars and a a 150k house might be paying more in taxes........OTHERWISE, your example doesn't hold water.
In my own example, I have to try pretty dang hard to come up with 40%. REALLY HARD.....but hey I guess we will have to agree to disagree........




Reply With Quote