IMO whens its all over Eli is going to be remembered as good or better than Peyton. The Super Bowl rings are an indicator of how good the team was on that day not necessarily the QB.....but he has more. If Eli stays the course and puts up above average stats plus keeps winning rings he will go down as one of the best. If he stays where he is with all the money and prestige of New York he has an even better shot of surpassing his big bro.