I've always had better average size on Cumberland than I ever did on Dale Hollow. I admit it is nice to get on numbers of Smallies every now & then on Dale Hollow, but would rather catch the bigger average fish on Cumberland. One can be just as good or bad as the other on any given day in my opinion. I usually end up on Cumberland because it's 1: closer & 2: I know it a lot better, but I also think when it comes to floatnfly fishing that Dale hollow is usually the better of the two.