Two bass pro reels and a couple of Garcia black max reels the anti reverse goes in and out. It cost me a couple of good fish this weekend so now it has to fixed or looking into getting new reels. I know these are no where near high dollar reels but I like them. Mainly happens when cranking or a strong hook set.
There's only two things it can be on a bait caster. Manufactures either use a anti-reverse bearing or a anti-reverse paw. On your BPS reels, you can check your reel schematic online at BPS reel repair to see what you've got or you can send your reel back. If it's an old Garcia that has a paw you can order it from any reel repair website. Be careful sometime they make them can tricky to get apart and reassemble.