The Choke hold was a contributing factor but
[QUOTE=Tim_T;540338]I don't see how you could do anything but indict this officer.
"The cause of Garner’s death was “compression of neck (chokehold), compression of chest and prone positioning during physical restraint by police,” the medical examiner’s office has said. The New York City Police Department prohibits chokeholds. The death was ruled a homicide."
This is a completely different case than what happened in Ferguson. There is video evidence of the chokehold being applied (against department policy) and the coroner's office report said that was the main cause of the death. IMO there has to be some type of charge.[/QUOTE]
I really didn't know much about this until yesterday when it was on TV all day long. So I watched the video of the police trying to arrest this man. I saw one officer get behind the man and grab him around the neck and head and take him down to the ground. I timed the choke hold and think it lasted for about 8 seconds before the officer released his hold around the neck and then press the suspects head down onto the concrete.
The guy was suppose to be illegally selling cigarettes on the streets or something. So they were going to cuff him. Now it's standard Procedure to take someone down to the ground if they resist arrest. But they did this pretty quick IMHO. The guy was not really fighting. He didn't try to hit the officers as all he did was say leave me alone and backup.
But the guy was morbidly obese and that alone can lead to a death if you are laying down the wrong way. He probably had a bad heart too. When one gets that big the heart has to work extra hard to pump blood. I'd be willing to guess that he has CAD too. As big as he was and him being black. Blacks are more subject to CAD and heart disease if they are big like him. It might have something to do with the fact that they live in a world with more white and that they live under more stress as a result of their environment.
I really do wonder if the police actually were trying to kill this man. He was just so big that they were not sure how else to cuff him without using lots of force. How do you get a man whos that tall and weights 350 lbs down on the ground in order to put his hands behind his back to put the cuffs on without using force if he is resisting the police?
Here is the kicker though. Why did they even have to arrest him? He was just trying to sell some cigarette to make some money. That's a pretty minor offence IMHO. Now once he resisted arrest the police had the right and duty to subdue him. If he has been in shape and had not be morbidly obese I'd bet that he would still be alive now. If they had not tried to arrest him he would be alive too. But I'd bet that eventually if he didn't lose the weight that he would be suffering from heart disease.
He said that he could not breath. But he was talking so he could breath. If he could not really breath he would not be able to talk that much. I think that the guy died of stress. His heart just gave out. The films that I saw clearly show the paramedic checking for a pulse on his neck. Carotid Artery is there and that artery is easy to use to check for a pulse. He evidently still have a pulse or she would have started CPR. And I heard that they said he was still breathing. As a former EMT I've had to assess patients in the field many times and if they have an open airway, are breathing and have a pulse you don't have to start CPR. You just package them up using care to not do any damage and take them to the ER for further evaluation by the Doctors. I didn't see what the medics did or did not do in the ambulance as there was no video shown of them in the ambulance. But I did hear that he died on the way to the hospital.
We just have too many people in this world not and conflict is a result of too many people living in too close proximity. This is why there is more crime in the crowded city than out in the rural areas. People who live out in the rural areas are less crowded and suffer from much less stress. They probably also will live longer. They have less pollution and less noise. When I went to Chicago and stayed in the Palmer House back in 1977 I remember hearing sirens almost all the time. There was always a police car, ambulance or fire truck blowing their sirens day and night in that city's downtown area. Of course when you are up 8 stories in the air you can see pretty far out into the city and you hear a lot more from up there than you would down at street level. But the point is that the city was much more stressful and noisy that what I was used to. I lived out in the quiet county where the only noise that I heard was the TV or the neighbors beagles barking at a cat or raccoon in the yard. I grew up listening to the birds singing and that was as loud at it normally got.
I also have a heart condition now. So if I had to endure what they put the guy though I too might suffer some form of heart attack. Police need to find a better way to arrest people where they don't kill people. Because killing people without a trial and judges order is just wrong. Some still think that the death penalty is wrong. I won't go that far but there are times when innocent people are sentenced to death when they should not have been. RE the Innocence Project that Barry Scheck Started and used DNR testing to prove some people innocent of the crimes that they were convicted of.
I do know this. I'm getting tired of all this violence and killing and I'm really getting tired of seeing all the protesters walking around the city's day and night. American is going downhill I guess.
[url]http://www.innocenceproject.org/about/[/url]
I enjoly photography and like to get the birds up close
[QUOTE=kygorski;540352]I saw earlier in one of your posts that you are a bird feeder, so am I. But lately its getting to expensive, but before I went on social security, I was a fanatic. We moved to the boonies from the city, and loved it. We had no neighbors in sight, woods on all sides, a gravel road to the home. never locked a door, left the keys in the vechicles, Our kids hated it! We had deer at the feeders, turkeys, quail, even a grouse.squirrels, racoons, possum. had to move because of health problems, and hate it. Everyone at church thought we were hermits.[/QUOTE]
I feed them sunflower seeds and some peanuts for the blue jays. I had a heart attack 5 years ago last March and decided that I needed a new hobby that was less stressful and that I could do easily. But now my eye sight is getting worse and it's hard to see. I just got back from the eye surgeon office today where he did another minor eye operation to try to correct my vision in one of my eyes. I have to have another operation on the other eye in a few weeks. That one will take a while to recover from. Maybe a year.
I buy the sunflower seeds at the big box stores in the bigger bags to save money. It's cheaper that way. I use to buy the smaller bags of all types of bird seed and that was expensive. Most all the birds that come to my feeders eat the sunflower seeds. The Morning Doves love them as do the cardinals. The other smaller birds even eat them. Some will pick up one seed and fly off to eat it and other's will stay at the feeder and eat a bunch of seed at one time. I've got a couple of books that help me ID the birds but they are hard for me to see unless I take a picture of them and look at it later. I can shoot them with an 18 megapixel Canon DSLR using a Nifty Two Fifty Lens from Cannon and they pictures look pretty good. I'd do more photography after I get my eye surgeries finished hopefully.
I got more interested in bird watching after I learned that they are the decedents of the dinosaurs. Now I look at a Blue Jay and try to see it as a miniature T Rex. LOL Imagine being a small bug or worm and having to fight off a Blue Jay or Crow? That would be like a human trying to outrun a 30 ft long T Rex 65 million years ago.
Did you know that dinosaurs remains have been found that shows that hey had feathers. Both the birds today and the Dinosaurs of years ago had hollow bones making them lighter in weight. This allows the birds to fly. And they are finding evidence that the dinosaurs were also warm blooded like the birds today.
Twice I use to live in a more secluded area but the surrounding land was developed and homes were built behind my homes. I lived on a street with only four house and just this last week they are building 4 more homes at the end of my dead end street. This is in addition to the other 12 houses already built in the last 20 years after I moved here.
Private lawyers are better than public defenders I guess
[QUOTE=kygorski;540351]I have a step son, who I've never met outside of prison.He's been fighting his sentence for over 20 years. I promised his mother i wouldn't forget him, and write often anf send a few bucks when he needs it. Its almost a 250 mile drive, and I don't see him that often, many times because of "lock down", a long drive wasted.He may have a valid case, three of them arrested for a robbery, the first one acquited, the second one turned states witness, and had several priors forgotten about. theres a lot more, but police bias was a factor. His mother and father both died while he was in prison, his siblings have more or less forgotten about him. He had a public defender, and he got life no parole.There are a lot of peculiar circumstances, so I'm biased. But I believe if he could have afforded a private lawyer he would have been acquitted.[/QUOTE]
I would think that a more experienced private lawyer who specialized in criminal law and trials would be better than a young lawyer working in the pubic defenders office who has very little trial experience .... yet. They work there to gain the experience and maybe because they care about poor people who can't always afford a expensive private law firm.
There are probably a lot of innocent people in prison today due to eye witness testimony that can and is flawed a lot of the time. I just watched a show on the "History Channel" which talkeda bout how human memory can be fooled and distorted. People can change there memory to try to fit the facts of a case and this happened in the Ferguson, Missouri Grand Jury testimony.